Nostalgic Rumblings
The Ramblings of an Old Man




If you appreciate the lists and websites, please consider contributing to their maintenance.


Categories


October 2004
S M T W T F S
« Sep   Nov »
 12
3456789
10111213141516
17181920212223
24252627282930
31  


Search:


Contact Webmaster


Links


Meta

  • RSS 2.0

    The main feed; in a news aggrigator, it's the news items, in a podcast client, it's the media files


  • Comments RSS 2.0

    This is the feed for global comments (any comment made to the board); each entry has a seperate comments feed, too


© 2004 L.O.F. Communications;
All Rights Reserved

Times listed are U.S. Eastern

We don't need no much stinkin' CSS...


 
Please Keep These Pages Free; Check Out Our Sponsors by Clicking the Banner!


Unfiltered Newsgroups with NGroups!


 

10/4/2004


Review: The Bob Edwards Show

Filed under: Radio Today — Charlie Summers @ 12:54 pm

Oh, shut up, Charlie. There’s no bloody way you’re going to be anything approaching unbiased, so quit pretending you’re going to do anything approaching a review.

 

Let me put it this way: my morning, for the first time since April, started the way it was supposed to start. And to steal a line from one of the XM promos, “I’m a happy man!”

After a short history piece about the launch of Sputnik 1 back in 1957, he proceeded to launch The Bob Edwards Show. (Good thing he didn’t instead relate the opening of the show to the premier of Leave it to Beaver, which also began on this date in 1957! And to just for a second pretend to do a show opening, “It’s the anniversary of the birth of Damon Runyon in 1884, and the birthday of Charlton Heston, who is 80 today.”)

Almost immediately thereafter he cracked me up…when describing the troubles back in March, he noted that he had hosted a daily news show for almost thirty years, and the executives at NPR told him he, “should never do that again…” Then into a lengthy interview with David Broder about the upcoming news of the week (this will be a Monday morning feature on the show), and a chat with USA TODAY Supreme Court reporter Joan Biskupic about the upcoming session which begins today.

The frontpiece of the premier show was a fascinating interview with Walter Cronkite, and it’s here I think better than anywhere else on this program where Bob’s style shows through. He gently questions, then gets the hell out of the way, allowing his guest to answer in any way he wishes, with gentle prompts and follow-ups, allowing the interview to go whatever way the guest’s answers take it.

I am a little sorry about one thing, though…when breaking, he’s only updating us on what happening after the break. I admit I kinda miss, “The time is 19 minutes past the hour…”

I’m also sorry he’s decided not to continue his “returns;” whether or not one of the guys who fired him created them or not, it’s something that is intimately connected to him.

I was also a little surprised that BBC News on the hour/half-hour wasn’t aired; but then, I’m of two minds on this. On the one hand, I’d like to be updated on the news I missed while I was asleep, but on the other hand it would remove eight minutes from the program. I’ll need to think about this for a week or two before I decide which is the more important.

The second half-hour is comprised of pre-recorded “soft-news” interviews, promoting books, movies, CDs, films, whatever. Again, two minds; he does an amazing job pulling out of people interesting and surprising stories, even those people I’m not particularly interested in. On the other, by and large I’m a whole lot more interested in the Supreme Court than I am in salsa music from Cuba. I know, I know, this isn’t Morning Edition (that show died last April), but still.

Bob referred to this as, “non-commercial public radio,” which isn’t exactly accurate…XMPR is instead technically “commercial public radio.” Not a thing wrong with that, though - instead of “donating,” I pay a commercial entity outright for the ability to hear the programs. I hope XM makes one helluva profit off of us, and continues to produce new and exciting public radio-style programs. I also admit to disagreeing strongly with Bob about supporting NPR member stations. These stations did not support Bob when he was foolishly removed as host of ME, so I don’t see a whole lot of reason to support them. I also disagree that “they” produce the programming on XMPR - a select few produce the programming, and I’m already supporting them by my XM subscription fees (you don’t think the stations are donating the programs to XM, do you?). The locals have gotten so intimidated by NPR that they roll over even when NPR becomes self-destructive. Bob’s a much bigger man than I am - I believe they do not deserve our support. Take the money you’d normally give to your local NPR member station and use it to buy an XM radio and subscription. This way, you an support quality public radio without supporting NPR…and get a heckuva lot of other options in music and talk as a bonus!

Ok, enough sermonizing. Bob closed out this morning’s show by acknowledging his staff; not only mentioning their names, but giving their bona fides. Sounds like one helluva team.

Lemme go back to where I started; for the first morning since April, the day started right. As I sit here listening to the rebroadcast, drinking my grande cappuccino and typing this on my Macintosh, everything seems right with the world for the first time since NPR released that moronic press release saying that Bob “chose” to leave the ME post. The little things just aren’t going to bother me this morning.

If you missed the program, or are not currently a subscriber to XM Satellite Radio, you can hear the program each day for the first week, between October 4th and October 8th, at the XM Radio website. They are “looping” the program, so you can come in any time and listen.


TrackBack URI    RSS feed for comments on this post.   Post ID: 218


3 Responses to “Review: The Bob Edwards Show” »

     

  1. Russ Gifford Says:

    Thank you for the update, and the web url!!!! Some of us are … well, behind the Times, I guess! But here’s hoping I’ll be “caught up” by next week!

    —Russ

    PS: Enjoyed the notes on the trip west and the photos, as well!

  2.  

  3. Judy Galloway Says:

    Yes, I am too happy to have Bob back to be objective about reviewing the show. I’m thinking maybe he needs some kind of music/theme song (or is that just harking back to the good ole days at ME?). But I really thought, a time or 2, he was going to slip up and say “this is Morning Edition” instead of “this is the Bob Edwards Show”–there was just a tiny hesitation or something.
    All in all, I too am a happy (wo)man! The long, long, dry season is over!
    I also heard Scott Simon’s close…was actually surprised he was “allowed” to say that someone was leaving to “join Bob at XMPR”. I’m worried NPR will sue XM for poaching key employees (too bad Kernis, Klose, et al).
    Charlie, keep up the good work (writing)!

  4.  

  5. Ivy Bayard Says:

    I sent a message saying, My world is back in orbit! I have been listening on the web because, of course, I don’t have my home kit yet. Yesterday the transmission was dropping out so badly, I go into my car to do some errands for the second play. I wanted to hear the person talking about her article in the Columbia Journalism Review because I sent the link to it to my newspaper. Anyway, I realized I can’t keep doing that, so I sent away for a power cord yesterday and I hope that the radio transmission will work for next week.

    I agree with you about the piece on Cuban music lasting longer than my interest in the subject, but I found the other days more interesting. I think Bob is finding his comfort level. I know I am so grateful to have his voice back in my world. I was even listening happily to his promos before the show started!

    Enjoy your blog, but was dismayed to read your thoughts about the new person substituting on Sunday. I heard her and didn’t make any connections except wondering why they were trying out a new person in that slot. I think if they mess with Scott, it will set off another storm of protest. For all the good it will do!


Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment (if not already registered, it only takes a moment - this is unfortunately necessary thanks to the slime who send blog comment spam advertising their illegal scams...).